Mumin Salih

Poor Mohammed, or was he?

Mohammed is portrayed, by Muslims as well as many non Muslims, as a poor man who dedicated his life to deliver Allah's message to mankind. He is usually associated with a simplistic life style that lacks the lavishness enjoyed by the rich and famous of his time. In the minds of Muslims, Mohammed's image is that of a determined messenger of Allah who was not deterred by the hardship and the persecution he suffered at the hands of the Meccan Arabs (1). Such representation of Mohammed as savour, who had no material ambitions or earthy desires and achieved no personal gains, fits well in the image of the 'perfect hero', which Muslims aim to paint for him. Mohammed's early childhood as an orphan, who lost his father before he was born and lost his mother at the age six, provided the Muslims with a convenient readymade foundation on which they built their desired image of their hero. Such image of Mohammed's life style is one of Islam's strange ironies because it is believed despite the evidence to the contrary. Such claim about a simplistic Mohammed is a clever mental illusion that distracts the mind from seeing the obvious and works well even on people who are critical of Mohammed. The secret of the success of this mental trick lies in the different perception of luxury in the seventh century Arabia. People have different tastes and priorities in life; what is considered to have a high value by some people may have no value at all to others. The Arabs' in general were not keen on appearances and the other manifestations of high class or royalty. Managing wealth depends on personal taste, culture and the available resources, all of which were poorly developed in Arabia compared to the other nations of the time like the Romans and the Persians.
The Arabs have always been loyal to their tradition, which explains why Islam is shaped to agree with those traditions. Even today, departing from the local traditions is considered a serious social offence that most modern Arabs try to avoid. In the seventh century Arabia, it was considered a social duty for the chief of the tribe to open his house to all, a tradition that is still alive in many Arab societies today. Such a tradition was considered as a sign of generosity and an indication of distinction and social prominence. In the seventh century, it was traditionally unacceptable for the wealthy Arabs, who were normally eminent figures in their tribes, to be segregated from the rest of their societies by guards or palace walls. Arabic literature is rich in examples that emphasise that tradition. I am not sure if it is still the case, but it was customary for the rulers in the Gulf States to offer coffee in their lounges, called diwan, to ordinary people, who seize the opportunity to hand their complaints, or requests for help, directly to the rulers. In addition to the cultural reason, there were other reasons for the lack of palaces, and other manifestations of luxury, in Arabia. The Arabs, in the seventh century, did not have the technology or the resources to build spectacular palaces on the scale known in Persia or Syria. A simple tent was a practical and simple answer to the hot desert climate. Those who visit the Gulf States may be surprised to see that the wealthy Arabs still use tents which they erect next to their palaces. Gaddafi's tent is a living reminder, not just of the Libyan leader's eccentricity, but also of that old desert tradition. It is true that Mohammed did not own spectacular palaces, but neither did any other wealthy leader in Arabia. In the absence of accurate indicators of capital such as bank accounts, Mohammed's wealth has to be gauged using the suitable measures of the time. In other words, we have to look at his assets in the form of properties, as well as his other possessions. This article is not designed to provide an estimate of Mohammed's wealth, but it sheds some light on only some of his assets and refutes the claims that he was poor or had a simplistic life style. As usual, our sources are the authentic Islamic history sources; it is either that the Islamic history is completely wrong (and Islam is a big lie) or that Mohammed was a corrupt 'millionaire' (and also Islam is a big lie).

Read more...

The Quran - The Mountains are Extra Terrestrial

By Mumin Salih

Read more...

politics (256) religion (237) human rights (189) freethinker (183) society (169) activism (133) terrorism (121) international (111) MuktoMona Editor (101) Avijit Roy (92) philosophy (86) Bhaskar (67) culture (64) india (55) science (53) secularism (49) A Rahman (49) Guest Writer (48) Tonoy Emroz (48) free speech (44) personality (42) Sukhamaya Bain (40) blogger killings (39) A. H. Jaffor Ullah (37) freethinking (33) islam (33) women rights (31) literature (27) 1971 genocide (27) William Gomes (27) Abul Kasem (27) bangladeshi bloggers (26) education (24) liberation war (24) shahbagh movement 2013 (23) Bonya Ahmed (22) Mehedi Hassan (22) Jiten Roy (21) farhad (21) arrested bloggers writings (19) history (18) koran (18) freedom of expression (15) Syed Kamran Mirza (14) blogger killing (13) celebration (13) Mohsin Siddique (13) Adnan Lermontov (12) richard dawkins (11) Jahed (11) Anwarul Kabir (11) Jahed Ahmed (10) shabbir (10) book (10) Rainer Ebert (10) evolution (9) ajoy roy (9) darwin day (9) Sujit Das (9) koranic contradictions (9) Biplab Pal (8) bd election 2008 (8) Md Maruf Hasan (7) hinduism (7) economics (7) Muktar Ahmed Mukul (7) love (6) Subrata Shuvo (6) Mahfuzur Rahman (6) Mozammel H Khan (6) teki_admin (6) Ripan Kumar Biswas (6) Trisha Ahmed (5) flash fiction (5) seminar (5) war crimes (5) Dipen Bhattacharya (5) Siddhartha Dhar (5) environment (5) barack obama (5) Bijon Sarma (5) poem (4) astronomy (4) Raihan Abir (4) Shabnam Nadiya (4) violence (4) buttertoes (4) Mizan Rahman (4) obama (4) christianity (4) muhammad (4) Ram Puniyani (4) liberation war crime trial (4) bdr revolt (4) bdr mutiny (4) conflict palestinian-israel (4) homosexuality (3) health (3) corruption (3) lgbt (3) gay rights (3) lesbian (3) avijit english (3) Dhrubo (3) election (3) us election (3) Nripen Sarker (3) pseudoscience (3) violation of koran (3) Meera Nanda (3) criticism of islam (3) e-book (3) Sentu Tikadar (3) darwin day celebration (3) humayun azad (2) lifestyle (2) short story (2) blasphemy (2) law (2) constitution (2) lgbt rights (2) fiction (2) Shabbir Ahmed (2) marriage (2) section 377 (2) Rashad Ullah (2) stereotyping (2) cosmos (2) shuborna senjuti (2) usa (2) martyr intellectual day (2) creationism (2) shazzad (2) grameen bank (2) dr. yunus (2) Akbar Hussain (2) Mumin Salih (2) pakistan (2) rationalism (2) sheikh mujib (2) Tarek Fatah (2) superstition (2) Srinivas Kakkilaya (2) Simi Chowdhury (1) atheism (1) Mehzabin Ahmed (1) Razel (1) afganistan (1) covid 19 (1) covid19 (1) michael chakma (1) cht (1) health &amp (1) bengali literature (1) breast cancer (1) bonoful (1) translation (1) digital security act 2018 (1) shahidul alam (1) muktomona (1) school students (1) road safety (1) bangladesh bloggers (1) shahjahan bachchu (1) Aniruddha Sohan (1) Abdur Rahim (1) minority torture (1) war crims (1) Shafiul Joy (1) Sam Virakocha Sinha (1) Bottle Bhut (1) blogg (1) Foring Camelia (1) Shaibal Chakraborty (1) Nigel Hughes (1) niloy neel (1) Arifur Rahman (1) equality (1) gay marriage (1) interfaith (1) interfaith marriage (1) interreligious marriage (1) marriage equality (1) same-sex marriage (1) special marriage act (1) voltaire lecture 2015 (1) rafid (1) Jawshan Ara Shatil (1) vigil (1) memorial (1) Salman Rahman (1) experience (1) LGBTQ (1) nonfiction (1) Maruf Rosul (1) capitalism (1) democracy (1) malaysia (1) nationalism (1) blasphemy day 2013 (1) hijra (1) transgender (1) sexual identity (1) Tanvir Alim (1) allachalaina (1) Bhaswati Mazumder (1) writeup of asif mohiuddin (1) Irtishad Ahmad (1) discrimination (1) hifazat-e-islam (1) Md. Jane Alam (1) Atheist Bloggers (1) Tanveer Ibn Haresh (1) fraud (1) child domestic work (1) child labour (1) children (1) domestic work (1) maids (1) death penalty (1) capital punishment (1) mbi munshi's jamat connection (1) mbi munshi's pakistani connection (1) bangla spring (1) lgb (1) gay (1) bisexual (1) sexual orientation (1) gun control (1) innocence of muslims (1) youtube (1) Stephanie McMillan (1) yellowstone national park (1) travel (1) software (1) journalism (1) nature (1) ecology (1) M R Badhan (1) dgfi (1) nsi (1) rab (1) sexual misconduct (1) gias ahmed (1) desh tv (1) minorities (1) julian assange (1) micro credit (1) Jamal Hasan (1) add new tag (1) bangladesh high court (1) hijab (1) misogyny (1) M. Harun uz Zaman (1) ekushe (1) language movement (1) hasina (1) afghanistan (1) sheikh mujib killing (1) ziaur rahman (1) justice in bangladesh (1) bangladesh military (1) abraham lincoln (1) bangladesh (1) Adil Mahmood (1) Bangladesh Genocide Studies (1) nobel peace prize (1) new earliest hominid (1) pre-lucy (1) ardi (1) moulavi-sir (1) 9/11 conspiracy theory (1) theories (1) debunk (1) skeptic (1) demand on september 11 (1) Anindyasundar (1) allah (1) islamic god (1) swine flu (1) h1n1 (1) ramadan (1) senator ted kennedy (1) bangladesh genocide (1) bangladesh liberation war (1) pakistani military (1) (re)reading taslima (1) bangabandhu (1) august 15 (1) bangabandhu killing (1) sheikh mujibur rahman (1) 1947 partition (1) gandhi (1) intelligent design (1) random thoughts (1) thesis on leaving islam (1) medical physics (1) british colonialism (1) Shahidul Islam (1) tajuddin ahmed (1) patriot (1) honor killing (1) relationship (1) lunar landing (1) apollo 11 (1) neil armstrong (1) nasa (1) research (1) universities of bangladesh (1) islamic heaven (1) huris (1) houris (1) virgins (1) islamic brothel (1) Shazzad Khan (1) poetry (1) iran election 2009 (1) ayatollah ahmadinejad (1) mousavi (1) freedom fighter (1) mcnamara (1) india election 2009 (1) education: let us think (1) cannibalizing islam (1) islam against islam (1) dancing with dead bodies (1) west bengal (1) islamic hell (1) bjp (1) student politics (1) al government (1) political parties (1) masters (1) islamic voodoos (1) power crisis (1) political vengeance (1) correction (1) genocide of 1971 (1) let the good sense prevail (1) ekushey (1) language day celebration (1) mother language day (1) koranic contradiction (1) mathematics (1) bible contradictions (1) iraq (1) islam and politics (1)